From the platform at the Bedford Hills Metro-North station, you can see most of Adams Street. On the corner is the brick wall of Bedford Grab & Go at 1 Adams St., which faces the tracks. Farther up the block are two older commercial buildings that are about to be torn down. Behind you is Depot Plaza, with the historic station building at its center. The Town of Bedford leases that building from the MTA and has been trying to find a tenant for it. The Recorder reported in October that the face of downtown Bedford Hills "is likely to undergo some dramatic changes in the not-too-distant future."
If you're comparing the parts of Bedford, that block says more about Bedford Hills than any town-wide price chart does. The town's median sale price mostly tracks which large properties happened to close in a given month. Bedford Hills is the one hamlet where the town is adding small homes within walking distance of the train.
What the Bedford median is actually averaging
Bedford is one town made up of distinct hamlets. Westchester County's visitor bureau describes Bedford Village around its historic green, Bedford Hills as a business center built around its railroad station, and Katonah with its Victorian architecture. A Bedford single-family report counts all of those hamlets together, along with Bedford Corners.
In September 2026, Bedford's single-family median was $1,500,000 across 33 closings, according to the OneKey MLS-based monthly report that Madison & Park Appraisal analyzed in late October. The average sale price that same month was $2,161,708. When the average sits about 44% above the median, a few very large sales are pulling it up. The appraiser's own reading was that "a handful of large estate closings can lift both numbers without any change in what a typical in-hamlet house would bring."
One month later the picture flipped. The same report series showed an October 2026 median of $1,326,000 on 19 single-family closings, with an average of 58 days on market. The October drop came from a different, smaller set of sales closing, with fewer large estates among them. A narrower OneKey MLS cut of Bedford makes the point another way. Over the 12 months through September 2026, it showed a single-family median essentially flat, down 2.3%, across 78 closings.
The long view is steadier. The town's full-year single-family median went from $750,000 in 2017 to $1,350,000 in 2025, and the 2026 median through September 30 was about $1,434,500. For comparison, the Westchester County single-family median for the third quarter of 2026 was $1,189,000 across 1,625 closings, according to OneKey MLS.
None of these figures describes Bedford Hills. The appraiser put the reason plainly: multi-acre parcels with outbuildings, private wells and septic don't compete with in-hamlet Colonials on smaller lots, and Bedford's few condo and co-op sales are "a separate product altogether." A buyer looking at a smaller home near the Bedford Hills station is shopping in its own small market inside the town total. For that buyer, what is changing on the streets around the station matters more than the monthly median.
Six months on Adams Street
The clearest sign of where Bedford Hills is heading came at a Planning Board meeting this fall. The Recorder reported on Nov. 15 that the board voted unanimously to give final site plan approval to a two-story, 10-unit apartment building at 61-85 Adams St. The plan has eight one-bedroom and two two-bedroom apartments. Two of the ten are classified as affordable, and the old commercial buildings on the site will be demolished.
The process shows a hamlet open to small buildings near the train. The Recorder described it as "unusually smooth," with no opposition from neighbors, and six months from first presentation to final approval. The meetings dealt with what the block will look like. The developer redesigned the parking-lot lighting to cut glare and agreed to swap fountain grass and boxwood for native plants. A new sidewalk will also run past the building. The site will have 11 parking spaces of its own, and residents will also use passes for nearby lots, a setup that fits a block this close to the station.
A second proposal, a few doors down, has taken a slower path. Westfair reported in October on a four-story, 12-unit building called The Mark II. It would have 19 parking spaces, and two units would be priced as affordable to households at 60% of area median income. The Recorder lists the address as 59 Adams St. It says the board has raised concerns about the building's size and the massing of its facade, and that more design changes are likely before any approval. The paper also reported that the Bedford Hills Fire Department, which had opposed an earlier version, has since given its blessing.
Taken together, the two projects show where the line is. A low, small building near the train moved through in half a year. A taller one on the same street is being reshaped first. Both fit the direction of Bedford Together, the comprehensive plan the town adopted in April 2025, which calls for a broader range of housing types while keeping most of the town zoned single-family.
The rest of Depot Plaza
The apartment buildings are part of a wider effort. According to The Recorder's October report, the town has spent years trying to bring more life to the hamlet. Commuter traffic dropped sharply after the pandemic, and the town has already added sewers and new sidewalks. These are the other pieces now in motion.
| Spot | What's planned | Where it stands |
|---|---|---|
| 1 Adams St., Bedford Grab & Go | Mural on the brick wall facing the station | Contract requires completion by Dec. 31 |
| Bedford Hills station building | Tenant for the historic building the town leases from the MTA | Town hired a real estate attorney in August |
| 19 Babbitt Road | Neighborhood bar and grill in a former insurance office | Final site plan approval Sept. 14 |
| 2 Depot Plaza, the WorkHouse | Removal of the old pedestrian overpass | Variance granted Nov. 5 |
The mural is being paid for with remaining ARPA money and Downtown Improvement Grant funds, to make the station side of Adams Street more inviting. The bar and grill at 19 Babbitt Road sits next to a barbershop. It is approved to serve lunch and dinner seven days a week with a full bar, and it hasn't been named yet. For the station building, the attorney the town hired is looking at three options: finding a tenant, changing the town's lease, or possibly having the town take ownership so it can improve the building.
The overpass is the one change people who use the station will notice day to day. The Recorder reported that the 37-year-old bridge and staircase run from the WorkHouse office building over the tracks to the station parking lot. It has been closed for at least two years, and the MTA is requiring its removal. The MTA's own pedestrian bridge, a short distance away, remains the walkway between the parking lot, Depot Plaza and the platforms. Demolition is planned for a single weekend night between 11 p.m. and 5 a.m., most likely a Saturday, when train traffic is lightest. A 300-ton crane will lift out the girders.
Where the existing homes fit
Bedford Hills already has some walk-to-train housing. Lakeside at Bedford is a community of 59 townhomes on Haines Road, bordered by Lake Marie and Bedford Hills Memorial Park. It was completed in 1998, and its developer describes the Metro-North station as a short walk away. The Adams Street buildings will add apartments to that mix right next to the station, in the hamlet's business district.
That gives Bedford Hills a different set of housing choices from Bedford Village or Bedford Corners. The Harlem Line stops at both Bedford Hills and Katonah on the way to Grand Central, according to the MTA's timetable. Of the two, only Bedford Hills is adding new apartment buildings a few hundred feet from the platform. A move-up family might find the estate parcels the median price reflects. A first-time buyer, or someone looking for less upkeep, is more likely to find a townhome or a smaller in-hamlet house in Bedford Hills. Those are two different searches, and Bedford's averages blend them into one number. Our Bedford neighborhood page and our earlier piece on how Bedford's hamlets come together cover the rest of the town.
Questions buyers ask about Bedford Hills
Does Bedford's median price apply to a Bedford Hills home? Not reliably. The town figure includes multi-acre properties in Bedford Village and Bedford Corners, so a fair comparison for a Bedford Hills home is recent sales of similar homes on similar lots in Bedford Hills itself.
Will the new apartments change parking near the station? The 61-85 Adams St. building will have 11 parking spaces of its own and use passes for nearby lots for the rest, according to The Recorder's Nov. 15 report.
Is the station itself changing? The station building may get a tenant, and the private overpass from 2 Depot Plaza is coming down. The MTA's pedestrian bridge to the platforms stays in place.
If you're weighing Bedford Hills against the rest of Bedford, I'd love to walk Adams Street and Depot Plaza with you and look at what has actually sold near the station, house by house, instead of relying on the town median. Reach out to Sami Vecchiolla and let's connect.